The complaint about kahanism not giving us any solutions is mostly unfounded but has a bit of truth to it. And I feel like I'm obligated to respond as I had the misforture of reading this vomit of an article, that I can only discribe as a hit piece.
To start, the banning of KACH from the political arena is not the faliure of KACH, but a faliure of democracy/liberalism, a vindication of the idea that this state is ran by the deepstate elite, leading to the impossibility of any real opposition emerging, leading the currently existing opposition to be only a controlled one. Essentially transmiting the only answer, a physical deposing of traitorous state officials is the only unfortunate way of fixing this country. But even despite that, the ghost of Kahanism still remains and follows us everywhere, and the words of Rav Kahane keeps getting proven over and over again the further we go, and people notice it, so KACH is dead as a political entity, but it's ideas are clearly not, making it clearly, a resounding success. The article also writes that the KACH party didn't offer any solutions as in policy, which just comes to show how little the author actually knows of Rabbi Kahane's ideas. There are very clear economic, religious, militaristic, diplomatic and state policies that are presented in great detail in his books, brushing it off like it doesn't exist, is again, dishonest.
Also important to mention that Rabbi Meir Kahene didn't adovcate for an instant transition of Israel into a halahic state, he promised a few most necessary policies to secure our faith and people against the dangers of atheism, and he did consider the halahic state the ideal to be chased, but never actually made the halahic state his main policy, leaving his focus to more realistic and instantly required issues, which makes his popularity among secular Jews completely rational and not something to be ashamed of.
Next the article decides to go on a schizorant about how kahane is an undercover FBI agent who had an affair with a shiksa, which is a complete bollox hit piece, a bold accusation with no substance or evidence, seen it multible times with Trump, but for some reason the author decides to take it seriously, which is rather odd considering it's clearly a madeup story which becomes instantly apparent if one actually reads that one article. A compete disgrace and childness on the part of the author to even mention that.
The article also mentions the fact that most self proclaimed kahanists today lack the ideals of kahane, and that is unfortunately true, because most people who champion their imagery are diaspora Jews who's only connection with the Lord and with the people is the legacy of JDL, in reality, but if we look a bit beyond the slogans and images, if you ask any reasonable dissident right Jew about Kahane he will say that everything he said was correct and that he voted for him when he was electing, it's just that these people no longer wear the flag so pridefully because it's illegal and pointless considering it's death in a political arena.
Just to remind everyone of what Kahane predicted, and the solutions he found to these doom prophecies. He predicted the infiltration of leftists and arabs into the electoral politics, leading to more oppression of patriot and religious Jews, and the surrendering of lands that come with it. A solution to which is a rejection of electoral politics as a whole, he predicted the terrible surprise attacks that will happen if we do not transfer all arabs out of Israel, he also predicted the gradually increasing american dominance over us, which will result in Blinken-like handcuffing of our military goals because of the bribe that is the the US aid to Israel. Just to name a few, but the list is vast, and to conclude, the is either dishonest, or simply unaware of what Rabbi Meir Kahane advocated for and how his ideas live today, and that Rabbi Meir Kahane was completely right. Kahana Tzadak.
Unfortunately for all of us but fortunately for the ghost of Kahane, Iran, its proxies, and their worldwide network of fanbois may be providing the how.
If the main take away from Kahane for conservatives is admiration for his psychotic hate of Arabs, and the main take away from Kahane for liberals is disgust of his psychotic hate of Arabs, maybe his psychotic hate of Arabs was not actually an inconsequential part of his message like you are trying to argue.
The complaint about kahanism not giving us any solutions is mostly unfounded but has a bit of truth to it. And I feel like I'm obligated to respond as I had the misforture of reading this vomit of an article, that I can only discribe as a hit piece.
To start, the banning of KACH from the political arena is not the faliure of KACH, but a faliure of democracy/liberalism, a vindication of the idea that this state is ran by the deepstate elite, leading to the impossibility of any real opposition emerging, leading the currently existing opposition to be only a controlled one. Essentially transmiting the only answer, a physical deposing of traitorous state officials is the only unfortunate way of fixing this country. But even despite that, the ghost of Kahanism still remains and follows us everywhere, and the words of Rav Kahane keeps getting proven over and over again the further we go, and people notice it, so KACH is dead as a political entity, but it's ideas are clearly not, making it clearly, a resounding success. The article also writes that the KACH party didn't offer any solutions as in policy, which just comes to show how little the author actually knows of Rabbi Kahane's ideas. There are very clear economic, religious, militaristic, diplomatic and state policies that are presented in great detail in his books, brushing it off like it doesn't exist, is again, dishonest.
Also important to mention that Rabbi Meir Kahene didn't adovcate for an instant transition of Israel into a halahic state, he promised a few most necessary policies to secure our faith and people against the dangers of atheism, and he did consider the halahic state the ideal to be chased, but never actually made the halahic state his main policy, leaving his focus to more realistic and instantly required issues, which makes his popularity among secular Jews completely rational and not something to be ashamed of.
Next the article decides to go on a schizorant about how kahane is an undercover FBI agent who had an affair with a shiksa, which is a complete bollox hit piece, a bold accusation with no substance or evidence, seen it multible times with Trump, but for some reason the author decides to take it seriously, which is rather odd considering it's clearly a madeup story which becomes instantly apparent if one actually reads that one article. A compete disgrace and childness on the part of the author to even mention that.
The article also mentions the fact that most self proclaimed kahanists today lack the ideals of kahane, and that is unfortunately true, because most people who champion their imagery are diaspora Jews who's only connection with the Lord and with the people is the legacy of JDL, in reality, but if we look a bit beyond the slogans and images, if you ask any reasonable dissident right Jew about Kahane he will say that everything he said was correct and that he voted for him when he was electing, it's just that these people no longer wear the flag so pridefully because it's illegal and pointless considering it's death in a political arena.
Just to remind everyone of what Kahane predicted, and the solutions he found to these doom prophecies. He predicted the infiltration of leftists and arabs into the electoral politics, leading to more oppression of patriot and religious Jews, and the surrendering of lands that come with it. A solution to which is a rejection of electoral politics as a whole, he predicted the terrible surprise attacks that will happen if we do not transfer all arabs out of Israel, he also predicted the gradually increasing american dominance over us, which will result in Blinken-like handcuffing of our military goals because of the bribe that is the the US aid to Israel. Just to name a few, but the list is vast, and to conclude, the is either dishonest, or simply unaware of what Rabbi Meir Kahane advocated for and how his ideas live today, and that Rabbi Meir Kahane was completely right. Kahana Tzadak.
Was his picture altered to make him look so blotchy? He's hard to look at already
Never again!
No more Holohoaxes!
Unfortunately for all of us but fortunately for the ghost of Kahane, Iran, its proxies, and their worldwide network of fanbois may be providing the how.
If the main take away from Kahane for conservatives is admiration for his psychotic hate of Arabs, and the main take away from Kahane for liberals is disgust of his psychotic hate of Arabs, maybe his psychotic hate of Arabs was not actually an inconsequential part of his message like you are trying to argue.
This post went places I didn't expect!
I wonder why Jabotinsky isn't having a moment.
Because Jabotinsky's “Iron Wall" has been the de facto state of affairs since 1948, and failed miserably.